Strategic defence, evidence assessment and procedural representation under the Portuguese Criminal Code and Code of Criminal Procedure for domestic and international clients.
Clara Silva da Costa
Portuguese Bar Association No. 45229L
European Association of Lawyers | Criminal Litigation Background
Facing a criminal investigation or accusation in Portugal can be an unsettling experience. You may be unfamiliar with the Portuguese legal system, uncertain about your rights, or concerned about the consequences for your family, professional life, business or residence status. If you are a foreign national, the situation may be even more difficult when you do not speak Portuguese or understand how criminal proceedings work.
A criminal defense lawyer in Portugal can help you understand the allegations, explain your procedural rights, assess the available evidence and prepare an appropriate legal response. Early legal advice is particularly important when the authorities have requested an interview, conducted a search, seized property or taken someone into custody.
At CSC Advogada, Clara Silva da Costa brings a background in criminal and administrative litigation, alongside her wider experience in private-client and business legal matters. As a member of the Portuguese Bar Association, registered under number 45229L, she understands the importance of careful legal analysis, procedural safeguards and clear communication when clients face complex legal situations.
This guide explains how criminal proceedings work in Portugal, when to seek legal representation, what rights may be available to a defendant and what to consider when choosing legal assistance.
You do not need to wait until a criminal charge has been formally brought to seek legal advice. Depending on the circumstances, it may be sensible to speak to a lawyer as soon as you learn that you are the subject of a criminal investigation or have been asked to attend an interview with the police or another authority.
A criminal investigation can develop over time. Evidence may be gathered through witness interviews, documentary records, digital information, financial transactions, searches or other investigative measures permitted by law. The significance of these materials may not be immediately apparent to the person under investigation.
Legal advice can help you understand the nature of the procedure, the status you hold in the proceedings and the steps that may be appropriate at that stage.
The appropriate response depends on the facts. An informal request for information, a formal summons and a detention are not the same situation. Understanding the distinction is one of the first steps in assessing what legal assistance may be necessary.
Portugal's criminal justice system operates under a legal framework that includes the Portuguese Criminal Code and the Code of Criminal Procedure, together with legislation governing particular offences and procedural matters.
The Criminal Code establishes offences and the penalties that may apply. The Code of Criminal Procedure regulates how criminal cases are investigated and prosecuted, the rights and responsibilities of participants, the role of the courts and the procedures through which criminal allegations are determined.
The precise legal framework depends on the alleged conduct. A case involving alleged fraud, for example, may raise different evidential and legal questions from one involving assault, theft, a financial offence or a matter connected with a company.
It is important not to assume that an allegation automatically establishes criminal liability. The prosecution must proceed within the applicable legal framework, and the evidence must be assessed according to the requirements of Portuguese criminal procedure.
The official text of the Portuguese Code of Criminal Procedure is available through Diário da República, Portugal's official legal publication.
A criminal defence lawyer examines how the law applies to the specific allegations and available evidence. This may involve considering whether the conduct meets the legal elements of an offence, whether the evidence supports the allegation, whether procedural requirements have been respected and whether there are grounds to challenge particular measures or decisions.
The answer cannot be determined solely by the name of the offence or the fact that an investigation has started.
One of the first concepts that foreign nationals should understand is the Portuguese term arguido.
An arguido is a person who has formally acquired that procedural status in a criminal proceeding. It is often translated into English as “suspect” or “accused”, depending on the context, but the Portuguese term has a specific procedural meaning.
Under Article 58 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, formal constitution as an arguido is required in specified circumstances, including certain situations involving a person under investigation who is to be questioned as a suspect, the application of particular coercive measures or detention.
The status gives the person procedural rights and duties. It does not mean that the person has been convicted.
This distinction matters because the stages of a criminal case must not be confused. A person may be the subject of an investigation before an indictment is issued, and an indictment is not the same as a final conviction.
If you have been informed that you are an arguido, a lawyer can help clarify the procedural stage, the allegations being investigated and the steps that may be available to protect your position.
The Code of Criminal Procedure provides important safeguards for people who have acquired the status of arguido. The precise application of these rights depends on the circumstances and the stage of the case.
Article 61 recognises the right to appoint a lawyer or request the appointment of a defence lawyer. Article 64 identifies situations in which legal assistance is mandatory, including specified interrogations, the trial hearing and certain other procedural acts.
A lawyer can explain the legal significance of the allegations, advise on procedural decisions and assist with the preparation of the defence.
Where questioning or detention is involved, obtaining legal advice promptly is particularly important. You should not assume that a conversation with an authority is insignificant simply because a formal trial has not begun.
A person facing criminal proceedings must be informed of the facts attributed to them in accordance with the applicable procedural rules.
Understanding the alleged conduct is essential to preparing a meaningful response. The legal classification of the offence, the circumstances alleged and the evidence relied upon can all affect the defence strategy.
A lawyer can help distinguish the factual allegations from assumptions, interpretations or conclusions that still require examination.
Portuguese criminal procedure recognises an arguido's right not to answer questions about the facts attributed to them and about statements they have made concerning those facts, subject to the applicable legal framework.
This is an important safeguard. However, it should not be confused with a general permission to ignore every lawful procedural obligation. The rules applicable to identification, attendance and particular procedural acts may differ.
Before an interview, legal advice can help you understand what you are required to do, which questions concern the allegations and how to exercise your rights appropriately.
If you do not understand Portuguese sufficiently to follow the proceedings, interpretation or translation rights may be relevant under the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Language difficulties should not be treated as a minor administrative issue. A misunderstanding about the nature of a question, a procedural deadline or the meaning of a document can affect a person's ability to participate effectively.
A foreign national should raise any difficulty understanding the language with the relevant authority and seek legal advice about the interpretation and translation arrangements available in their circumstances.
The procedural rights recognised by Portuguese law may allow an arguido to participate in the investigation and instruction stages, propose evidence or investigative measures and appeal decisions where the law permits.
These rights do not mean that every request will be granted. The relevant authority or court must assess the request under the applicable rules.
A defence lawyer can evaluate which steps may be useful, what procedural requirements apply and whether an adverse decision may be challenged.
Criminal defence is not limited to representing a client at trial. Depending on the case and the stage of proceedings, legal work may begin much earlier.
The first task is to establish what has happened and what is known about the proceedings. This may involve reviewing a summons, police communication, court notification, decision or other document. The lawyer will need to understand the client's account, identify the relevant dates and establish whether any immediate procedural deadlines or restrictions apply.
At this stage, it is important to separate confirmed information from assumptions. A person may have heard that they are under investigation without knowing the precise legal status or the scope of the allegations.
The defence may need to examine documentary evidence, communications, financial records, witness accounts, technical reports or other materials relevant to the allegations. The availability of evidence depends on the procedural stage and the applicable access rules. Not every document will necessarily be available to the defence immediately.
The purpose of the review is to understand what the evidence actually establishes, where there may be gaps or inconsistencies and which questions require further investigation.
Questioning can be an important moment in criminal proceedings. A person may feel pressure to explain themselves quickly, particularly if they believe that cooperating will resolve the situation. However, the legal significance of an interview depends on the circumstances. Before answering questions about alleged criminal conduct, it is sensible to understand your rights and obtain appropriate legal advice.
A lawyer can explain the nature of the procedure, clarify the allegations where possible and advise on how to approach the interview within the applicable law.
Criminal proceedings are subject to procedural rules governing investigative measures, evidence, notifications, deadlines and court decisions. If a potential procedural problem arises, it must be assessed in context. Not every irregularity automatically makes evidence inadmissible or invalidates an entire proceeding.
The relevant question is whether the issue has legal significance and what remedy, if any, may be available.
The defence strategy must be based on the allegations, the evidence, the applicable law and the client's objectives. Depending on the case, the work may involve analysing the legal elements of an alleged offence, examining the reliability of evidence, identifying relevant witnesses, submitting requests permitted by law or preparing arguments for a hearing.
A sound defence is fact-specific. No lawyer can responsibly guarantee a particular result before the evidence and legal issues have been assessed.
Where the matter proceeds to court, the defence lawyer can assist with preparation, legal submissions, the examination of evidence and the client's participation in the proceedings. The trial process depends on the nature of the case and the applicable procedural rules. The court assesses the evidence and determines the issues before it according to law.
If a decision is unfavourable, the possibility of an appeal depends on the type of decision, the applicable grounds and procedural deadlines.
The legal issues vary considerably between criminal cases. The following are examples of matters in which an individual or business may need legal advice. They are not a statement that every category falls within a particular firm's specialist practice; the availability and scope of representation should be confirmed when the case is assessed.
Cases involving alleged fraud or financial misconduct may depend on the interpretation of transactions, communications, company records and the conduct attributed to particular individuals.
The analysis may need to distinguish between a contractual or commercial disagreement and conduct that may meet the legal requirements of a criminal offence. An unpaid invoice or failed business arrangement does not automatically establish fraud.
The underlying facts and evidence must be examined before any conclusion can be reached.
Cases involving alleged physical violence or threats may require careful examination of witness accounts, medical documentation, communications and the circumstances surrounding the incident.
The legal classification depends on the alleged conduct and the relevant statutory provisions. A lawyer can assess the issues that arise from the evidence and explain the procedural options available.
Allegations involving the taking, retention or use of property may raise questions about ownership, possession, intention and the circumstances in which the conduct occurred.
The existence of a dispute over property does not by itself resolve whether a criminal offence has taken place. The facts must be assessed against the relevant legal elements.
A criminal investigation may affect a company, its directors, employees or other individuals connected with its activities.
Depending on the facts, the matter may involve financial records, internal communications, corporate decision-making or the conduct of particular representatives. A company and an individual may have different procedural interests, so their legal positions should be assessed carefully.
It is also important to distinguish between a civil or commercial dispute and a criminal investigation, even where the same events give rise to both.
Foreign nationals may face additional practical difficulties when dealing with criminal proceedings in Portugal. These can include language barriers, unfamiliar procedures, travel arrangements and concerns about the consequences for residence or employment.
The criminal case and any immigration-related consequences are legally distinct questions, although the same facts may affect both. The implications for an individual's residence status or ability to travel should not be assumed; they require an assessment of the person's circumstances and the applicable rules.
Being detained can be stressful, particularly when you do not understand the language or the reasons for the measure. If you or a family member is detained in Portugal, consider the following steps:
The Code of Criminal Procedure provides for defence assistance in specified situations involving detained or imprisoned defendants. Ask to communicate with a lawyer and clarify how legal representation will be arranged.
The relevant authority should communicate the procedural information and rights required by law. If you do not understand Portuguese, raise the language issue and ask about interpretation.
Do not invent details to fill gaps in your memory. If you are uncertain about a fact, do not present an assumption as something you know.
Where lawful and practical, identify documents, messages or other materials that may be relevant to the case and tell your lawyer about them.
Your lawyer can help you understand the applicable obligations, deadlines and restrictions.
Detention and other coercive measures are governed by legal requirements. Whether a particular measure is justified or can be challenged depends on the circumstances and the applicable law.
If the situation is urgent, contact a Portuguese criminal defence lawyer or the appropriate local authorities without delay.
For an international client, the Portuguese criminal justice system can be unfamiliar even when the person has experience with legal proceedings in another country.
The first point to understand is that criminal procedure is governed by Portuguese law where the Portuguese authorities and courts have jurisdiction over the case. The terminology, procedural stages and rights may differ from those in the client's home country.
A lawyer should explain the process in language the client can understand and clarify where interpretation or translation is needed.
There may also be questions about travel, residence permits, employment, family responsibilities or the handling of property and financial assets. These issues should be assessed separately rather than assuming that a criminal allegation automatically determines every other legal matter.
For example, the consequences of a criminal proceeding for a foreign national may depend on the offence, the procedural status, the final outcome and the immigration rules applicable to that person. Advice should therefore be based on the specific facts and the relevant legal framework.
Where more than one legal system is involved, coordination with appropriately qualified legal professionals in other jurisdictions may be necessary.
Selecting legal representation is an important decision. The lawyer should be able to explain the process, identify the immediate priorities and give you a realistic understanding of the issues.
When assessing legal assistance, consider the following:
A criminal defence matter can involve sensitive personal and professional information. It is reasonable to ask how communications will be handled and what information the lawyer needs to assess the matter properly.
Clara Silva da Costa is the founder of CSC Advogada and has more than 14 years of legal experience. Her professional qualifications include a degree in Law, postgraduate training in Registries and Notarial Practice, and postgraduate training in Labour Law. She is registered with the Portuguese Bar Association under number 45229L and is a member of the European Association of Lawyers.
Her earlier professional background includes criminal and administrative litigation, including work on cases that received media attention. Her subsequent work has included private-client and business legal matters, together with real estate-related legal work.
This background provides relevant context for assessing legal disputes and matters involving interactions with public authorities. The appropriate experience and resources required for any particular criminal proceeding should nevertheless be confirmed based on the nature and complexity of the case.
At CSC Advogada, the starting point is to understand the client's situation, review the available information and explain the legal questions that need to be addressed. Clear communication is particularly important when a client is unfamiliar with Portuguese procedures or is concerned about the consequences of an investigation.
Where a matter requires specialist criminal defence expertise beyond the firm's confirmed scope, that should be identified transparently so that the client can consider suitable representation.